Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
Title: Do good historians have feelings?
Contributor(s): Atkinson, Alan Thomas  (author)
Publication Date: 2004
Handle Link:
Abstract: In reading our way through Australia's History Wars we often see the work of revisionists condemned as chilling or cruel. But the condemnation rarely amounts to an argument. It is usually meant as a kind of supplement to the writer's main points. However valid it might be as a moral judgement, from a scholarly point of view it is not clear what weight it is meant to carry. Robert Manne, writing in the 'Sydney Morning Herald' about Keith Windschuttle's 'The Fabrication of Aboriginal History', volume one, remarks on the "pitilessness" but then he quickly passes, in the same sentence, to a detailed account of the book's "internal self-contradictions". In 'Australian Historical Studies' Stuart Macintyre sets the same work within the broad sweep of history-writing since the eighteenth century and then similarly goes on, in his final sentences (about the counting of deaths), to suggest that while historians might disagree on such points, "at the very least we expect to find sympathy and compassion for the victims. I do not see it", he observes, "in this book".
Publication Type: Book Chapter
Source of Publication: The Historian's Conscience: Australian Historians on the Ethics of History, p. 17-27
Publisher: Melbourne University Press
Place of Publication: Carlton, Vic. Australia
ISBN: 0522851398
Field of Research (FOR): 210303 Australian History (excl Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander History)
HERDC Category Description: B1 Chapter in a Scholarly Book
Other Links:,M1
Statistics to Oct 2018: Visitors: 181
Views: 185
Downloads: 0
Appears in Collections:Book Chapter

Files in This Item:
2 files
File Description SizeFormat 
Show full item record

Page view(s)

checked on Mar 9, 2019
Google Media

Google ScholarTM


Items in Research UNE are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.